Starlink: When It Makes Sense to Use It (and When It Doesn’t)

In the rapidly expanding universe of internet connectivity, Starlink, a satellite internet service provided by SpaceX, has emerged as a game-changer for many. Its mission to provide high-speed internet across the globe, especially in underserved areas, has both intrigued and confused potential users about its best applications. This comprehensive look aims to demystify when it makes sense to opt for Starlink and when it might be better to stick with traditional internet services.

When It Makes Sense to Use Starlink

RV or Mobile Healthcare

For those living the nomadic life in an RV or operating mobile healthcare services, traditional wired broadband options are out of the question. Starlink offers a viable solution with its mobile satellite internet service. Its ability to provide reliable, high-speed internet on the go makes it an indispensable tool for remote workers, travelers, and mobile clinics, ensuring connectivity no matter the location.

Boat/Yacht/Marine Application

Maritime internet options have traditionally been limited to costly and slow satellite connections. Starlink changes the game for sailors, yacht owners, and marine operators by offering a high-speed, relatively affordable alternative. With its marine-specific plans, Starlink enables better navigation, communication, and entertainment options on the open sea, far surpassing previous offerings in both performance and price.

Aviation

For private aircraft owners, maintaining connectivity during flights has often been a luxury out of reach or tied to exorbitant costs. Starlink’s entrance into the aviation internet service market promises to revolutionize this, providing high-speed internet access mid-flight. This capability not only enhances the travel experience for passengers but also improves flight operations through better communication and real-time data exchange.

Very Rural and No Other Wired Internet Broadband Options

In remote and rural areas, where traditional internet service providers (ISPs) cannot or will not offer service due to logistical and financial constraints, Starlink shines as a beacon of connectivity. It bridges the digital divide for rural homes and businesses, offering speeds and latencies that rival, and in some cases surpass, those of urban broadband services.

Backup to Existing Wired Connection, When Fast Cellular Isn’t Available

Even in areas well-served by traditional ISPs, Starlink can serve an important role as a backup internet connection. For businesses and individuals who cannot afford downtime, Starlink provides an alternative when terrestrial broadband services fail, and fast cellular options are unavailable or unreliable. Its quick setup and portable equipment make it an ideal contingency plan.

When It Doesn’t Make Sense to Use Starlink

Other Broadband Wired Options Available

If you reside in an urban or suburban area with access to fiber, cable, or DSL internet services, opting for Starlink might not make the most sense. Traditional broadband options typically offer more consistent speeds and reliability for a lower cost. For everyday home and office use, wired connections remain the go-to choice for most consumers and businesses.

Video Conference Priorities 

Starlink, while offering impressive speeds for satellite internet, can sometimes suffer from latency issues due to the nature of satellite communication. For real-time applications such as video conferencing through platforms like Teams, Google Meets, or Zoom, even slight delays can disrupt the flow of conversation and lead to a frustrating user experience. In these cases, wired broadband services usually provide a more stable connection with lower latency.

VOIP Phone Traffic

Similar to video conferencing, Voice Over Internet Protocol (VOIP) phone services require stable and low-latency internet connections to function seamlessly. Delays or packet loss, which can occur more frequently with satellite internet like Starlink, might lead to dropped calls or poor call quality. For critical communication needs, especially in a professional setting, traditional broadband is often more reliable.

Low Latency Needs

For applications and tasks that demand the lowest possible latency—such as competitive online gaming, high-frequency stock trading, or certain types of remote work—Starlink may not be the best fit. The inherent delay in sending signals to space and back can’t compete with the milliseconds of latency offered by fiber-optic connections.

Is Starlink Right for You?

Starlink represents a monumental leap forward in satellite internet technology, offering high-speed connectivity in many areas of the world previously left in the digital dark. However, it’s not a one-size-fits-all solution. For those in remote areas, on the move, or in need of a reliable backup, Starlink is a groundbreaking option. Yet, for users with access to traditional broadband services or those requiring ultra-low latency, sticking with wired internet options might still be the best bet. As with any technology, assessing your specific needs and usage patterns is key to making the right choice.

The Synergy of 5G and Cloud Gaming: Transforming the Gaming Landscape

The gaming industry is currently undergoing a revolutionary transformation, driven by the intersection of 5G cellular networks and the rise of cloud gaming. In this article, we will explore the myriad advantages of cloud gaming and how the integration of 5G technology addresses crucial challenges, particularly in mitigating latency. Additionally, we will delve into the groundbreaking Low Latency, Low Loss, Scalable Throughput (L4S) standard, shedding light on its role in shaping the future of mobile cloud gaming.

Advantages of Cloud Gaming

Cloud gaming offers a host of advantages that are reshaping the gaming experience for enthusiasts worldwide. One of the most significant benefits is the elimination of storage concerns. Unlike traditional gaming methods that require substantial storage space for large game files and updates, cloud gaming stores and processes games on remote servers. This not only frees gamers from storage constraints but also eliminates the need for expensive hardware upgrades.

Another standout feature of cloud gaming is the instant access it provides. With game files stored remotely and pre-loaded on servers, gamers can dive into their favorite titles without enduring the waiting times associated with local installations. This seamless experience extends to updates, as cloud gaming platforms automatically maintain up-to-date servers, ensuring gamers benefit from the latest patches and enhancements without disruptions.

Cloud gaming also democratizes access to high-end gaming experiences by eliminating the need for costly hardware upgrades. Regardless of the device used, gamers can enjoy demanding titles, making gaming more accessible to enthusiasts with varying budgets. The portability of cloud gaming is evident in the ability to play games anywhere, anytime, using smartphones or other portable devices, adding a new dimension to the gaming experience.

The Convergence of Cloud Gaming and 5G

The transformative moment in the gaming industry occurs with the convergence of cloud gaming and 5G cellular service. The enhanced connectivity provided by 5G is instrumental in overcoming one of the key challenges of cloud gaming: latency. As 5G continues to roll out globally, it is poised to make cloud gaming the undisputed future of gaming, offering unprecedented flexibility, accessibility, and a truly immersive gaming experience.

Understanding Latency Challenges in Mobile Cloud Gaming

The dynamic landscape of cloud gaming introduces challenges related to network latency, throughput, and the upgrading of mobile networks. System latency, the delay between input and on-screen movement, becomes perceptible in cloud gaming due to the shift from local connections to internet-based platforms.

Mobile cloud gaming requires stable latency between 40 to 80 ms for a smooth gaming experience. Throughput, particularly on smartphones, plays a significant role, with baseline requirements starting at 15 Mbps for optimal resolution and frame rates.

Addressing Network Latency

The distance between end users and server locations significantly affects network latency. To mitigate this challenge, distributed servers situated closer to users can be instrumental. Placing servers within a service provider’s network provides optimal control over traffic. The integration of 5G technology, coupled with higher frequency bands, contributes to improving latency, laying the groundwork for an enhanced gaming experience. The evolution towards 5G Standalone (5G SA) and network slicing further refines the latency dynamics, promising a future where cloud gaming is seamlessly integrated into the on-the-go gaming experience.

The Role of L4S in Improving Latency

The Low Latency, Low Loss, Scalable Throughput (L4S) standard emerges as a crucial component in addressing latency challenges in cloud gaming. By reducing packet queuing congestion in networks, L4S introduces a setting within packets to adjust traffic flow immediately in the presence of congestion, minimizing buffering delays to single-digit milliseconds. While not yet widely adopted, major networking and ISP companies are involved in its development, paving the way for a more reliable and enjoyable cloud gaming experience.

Adoption and Collaboration for the Future

Though L4S adoption is in its early stages, major players like Comcast, Nokia, and Vodafone have been actively involved in its development. Trials conducted by Comcast with industry giants like Apple, Nvidia, and Valve showcase the commitment to advancing networking standards. Apple’s beta support for L4S in iOS 16 and macOS Sonoma, with plans for wider support in iOS 17, signals a positive trajectory for the adoption of this standard.

As the gaming industry charts its course over 5G networks, the integration of cloud gaming and advancements like L4S is pivotal for unlocking the full potential of on-the-go gaming. The collaboration between industry leaders, the adoption of innovative standards, and the ongoing evolution of 5G technology promise a future where gamers can enjoy a seamless and immersive experience, breaking down barriers and redefining the landscape of interactive entertainment.

Ookla SpeedTest Q3 2023 Results Show T-Mobile is Still in the Lead

As of yesterday, Ookla released their latest data on 5G speeds for the third quarter of 2023. Results are showing the difference between 5G and fixed broadband download speeds in the U.S. is getting closer.

Scoring a Median Download Speed of 221.57 Mbps, T-Mobile led the race. That’s compared to Verizon’s 153.79 Mbps median download speed, and AT&T’s 101.55 Mbps. With the exception of the latency scores, which AT&T led, T-Mobile was the winner in every category. However, each carrier saw increases in most categories. Other measurements compared were of Median Download and Upload Speeds, Median Multi-Server Latency, Consistency, and Video Score, as well as the same categories specific to 5G networks. 

In addition to reviewing speed test results, Ookla looked at device information. More specifically, the most popular devices at this time. This includes the iPhone 15 Pro and Pro Max models, the Galaxy S23 Ultra, Galaxy Z Fold4 and the Pixel 7 Pro. Overall, the Apple iPhones won with the highest speeds, but lost to the Galaxy devices in terms of latency. 

Lastly, state and city speeds were recorded and compared. Illinois took first place at the state level with the fastest median mobile download speed of 110.08 Mbps. T-Mobile was the fastest provider in 44 states and the District of Columbia during Q3 2023. Verizon was the fastest in North Dakota. As for South Dakota, Montana, Vermont, Maine, and Alaska – the results were too close to call. Among the 100 most populous cities in the U.S. Glendale, Arizona displayed the fastest median download speeds. T-Mobile was the fastest operator in 77 of these cities. Verizon Wireless was the fastest provider in El Paso, Texas, and AT&T was fastest in Las Vegas, Nevada. Results were statistically too close to call in 21 cities.

Ookla is using their Speedtest Intelligence service to find the overall Fastest Provider in terms of their Download Speeds. This service offers “up-to-date insights into global fixed broadband and mobile performance data based on millions of consumer-initiated tests taken every day with Speedtest®.” To see exactly what is being tested, checkout how Ookla collects data.  

Breaking Down Internet Speed Tests

The internet has become an integral part of modern life, enabling seamless communication, entertainment, and access to information. However, the quality of our online experiences greatly depends on the speed and reliability of our internet connection. Internet speed tests are essential tools that allow users to measure the performance of their internet connections accurately. In this article, we will delve into how internet speed tests work and what each result means.

What are Internet Speed Tests?

Internet speed tests are online tools or applications that assess the performance of your internet connection by measuring various metrics, such as ping time, jitter, download speed, and upload speed. These tests are user-friendly and readily available on various websites, making it easy for anyone to check their internet speeds.

How Internet Speed Tests Work

When you run an internet speed test, your device sends a series of data packets to a server hosted by the testing service. The server then measures how long it takes for the data packets to travel from your device to the server and back, providing key metrics related to your connection’s performance.

Understanding the Results

Ping Time (Latency)

Ping time, also known as latency, is the time it takes for a data packet to travel from your device to the server and back. It is measured in milliseconds (ms). Lower ping times indicate a more responsive and faster connection, which is crucial for online activities such as gaming, video conferencing, and real-time communication. High ping times can lead to delays, buffering, and lag.

Jitter

Jitter refers to the variability in the ping times of data packets. It is crucial for activities that require consistent and stable connections, like online gaming and VoIP (Voice over Internet Protocol) calls. Jitter is measured in milliseconds, and lower values indicate more stable connections.

Download Speed

Download speed measures how quickly data is transferred from the server to your device. It is usually represented in megabits per second (Mbps) or kilobits per second (Kbps). A higher download speed indicates faster loading times for websites, smoother video streaming, and quicker file downloads.

Upload Speed

Upload speed, also measured in Mbps or Kbps, indicates how quickly data is sent from your device to the server. This metric is crucial for activities like uploading large files, video conferencing, and online gaming (for games that require sending data to the server).

What Affects Internet Speed Test Results?

The results of an internet speed test can be influenced by several factors. One such factor is network congestion, which occurs when there is heavy internet traffic in your area or on your internet service provider’s (ISP) network, leading to reduced speeds. Additionally, the type of internet connection you have plays a significant role, as different technologies like DSL, cable, fiber-optic, and wireless offer varying speeds. The physical distance between your location and the test server is also a crucial consideration, as it can affect ping times and overall performance. Moreover, the performance of older devices or those with hardware issues may not be optimal during the test, further impacting the results. Being aware of these influencing factors allows users to interpret speed test results accurately and make informed decisions to enhance their internet connection’s performance.

Tips for Accurate Speed Testing

Achieving accurate speed test results is crucial for gaining a clear understanding of your internet connection’s performance. To ensure the most precise measurements, you can follow these essential tips:

  • Use a Wired Connection: Whenever possible, connect your device directly to the router using an Ethernet cable. Wired connections offer a more stable and consistent data transfer compared to WiFi, which can be susceptible to interference from other devices or physical obstacles. By using an Ethernet connection, you minimize the chances of external factors affecting the test, resulting in more reliable and accurate speed readings.
  • Close Background Applications: Before running the speed test, make sure to close any unnecessary applications or programs running on your device. Background applications may consume bandwidth and system resources, potentially skewing the test results. By closing these applications, you free up bandwidth for the speed test, providing a clearer picture of your actual internet speed without any external influences.
  • Choose the Right Server: Internet speed tests operate by sending data packets between your device and a test server hosted by the testing service. The physical distance between your location and the test server can impact ping times and overall performance. For more accurate results, select a test server that is geographically close to your current location. Choosing a nearby server reduces the chances of data traveling through a long and congested network, allowing the test to reflect your internet connection’s true capabilities.

Becoming an Informed Internet User

Understanding internet speed tests can be helpful in ensuring a smooth online experience. These tests offer valuable insights into the performance of our internet connections, helping us identify any potential issues and make informed decisions about our online activities. By measuring key metrics users can gauge the responsiveness, stability, and overall speed of their connections. However, it’s essential to consider various factors that may influence test results. Armed with this comprehensive knowledge of internet speed tests, users can optimize their internet experience, whether it be for gaming, video streaming, remote work, or staying connected with loved ones around the world. 

How Important is Latency to 5G Users?

According to Ericsson, user experience is all about “time-to-content” – in other words, how fast does my video start or my webpage load after I click to open it? Based on a study the company recently conducted, they found that latency is rarely a factor when it comes to user satisfaction. 

Reiner Ludwig, Strategic Product Manager in the Business Area Networks at Ericsson wrote a blog on just this – “Latency hardly impacts smartphone user experience in advanced 5G and 4G networks.”

In describing the study, Ludwig says they used high-end smartphones in a controlled environment. These were all requesting popular content (YouTube, Instagram, Amazon, eBay, Uber, etc) in an automated way. 

“For the latency measurements, we have ensured that sufficient up- and download speeds were available to the devices at all times: an uplink throughput “at click” of at least 1 Mbps and a downlink throughput “at click” of at least 20 Mbps,” he said. 

Tools and guidelines for the study were provided by Google on web.dev. This allowed them to see the relationship between time-to-content and latency, and time-to-content and up- and download speeds.

What is Latency?

Ludwig describes latency as the time it takes for a device to send one small ‘echo’ packet to the serving content server and the corresponding ‘echo-reply’ packet to return to the device. This period of time is also called the round-trip time. 

What isn’t latency? It’s NOT the same as time-to-content. This is where many people tend to misunderstand. 

Where is Low Latency Most Helpful? 

While low latency is important to online gamers, it’s more crucial for machines. 

“Machines, not humans, can benefit from the ultra-low and ultra-reliable latencies that only 5G can provide. For example, think about video-controlled high-precision robots in a smart factory. Here, you might see latencies below 10 ms, i.e., ultra-low, and without latency spikes exceeding 10 ms, i.e., ultra-reliable. Meeting these tough requirements is one of the key drivers behind Ericsson’s launch of a new product offering targeted at Time-Critical Communication,” says Ludwig.

Surprisingly, us humans are hardly able to tell the difference between 30 and 50ms of latency. Ludwig explains that 5G and 4G latency in the U.S. is usually less than 50 ms. This came from a 6 month analysis of Ookla’s speed test results, which were gathered from all across the U.S.

The takeaway here is that 5G (human) user experience is determined by speed, not much by latency. However, Ludwig admits, “Once 5G use cases such as virtual and augmented reality become mainstream, some aspects might need to be revisited.”

To view Ludwig’s blog in its entirety, see here.